Additionally, they decided to take a vacation at a critical juncture - the week of closing, without notice or planning - rendering them unreachable and leaving me in a difficult position.This experience has led me to question whether I need to stick with an attorney in the state where I'm purchasing property.

You would have to pay for the consultation, there are no free consultations for this sort of matter.You may also provide additional details here to receive free advice. 

I am a newer real estate agent who has fantastic credit and about $80K in savings.

We acquire additional liability insurance and third property manager where we have an attorney review the indemnification clause.

Every time the dirtbag tries to rent again, or buy anything on credit, it will pop up and stop them.You can take the recorded judgement to a collection agency.

@Daniel Schlittler   If you start one, let me know and I'll add it to the list.

In addition, what lenders have been best to work with from your experience?

What is the credit score looking like ? 

I live in Littleton and I'm planning on buying in the west Denver metro and I'm familiar with the area, but additional data points are always helpful.

I think it takes a while for your credit score to establish.