I have 2 other rentals that ideally can subsidize this, so, would I be better off holding onto it for the long haul and evening out eventually, or selling the property and getting something else?  

I know this isn't the conventional way to job search but I have been firing off applications for almost a year now and haven't been hearing back so I wanted to give something else a shot. 

Would be opened to a fair off market deal.

Are most investors using wholesalers to find off-market deals?

@Praveen Van  Not sure on a DSCR loan specifically but I have similar commercial loans, that are based off the rental income of the property. 

If it's not more than $5K, you're probably best off moving on. 

There are still a few good resources for Log Cabins or Off-Grid style properties in remote areas as well.  

Once you find the right tenant, it is a pretty hands off investment. 

This way you can ramp up your savings AND learn some RE skills.2.

It's 20% down but it doesn't go off DTI but income of the property (yes, even SFH for STR).