@Ashley Kehr I use a combination of Apartments.com for rent collection, RentSpree for tenant and background screening, and Stessa for accounting.

Quote from @Reed Rickenbach: John - as long as you are still following strict screening criteria I agree for single family.

Was the condo a good size unit and in good condition?  

It's difficult to see how a tenant will be after screened and signing a lease.

A good manager will handle everything from marketing to maintenance and tenant screening, saving you time and stress.Vendors and LandscapingBuilding a team of dependable vendors—like landscaping companies, contractors, and insurance agents—is critical.

Get you ducks in a row before committing.Also, not an expert in that area, but I cannot believe that a cabin double the size will do the same revenue. 

I started to notice some issues early on when I tried to get some new tenants screened and signed up. 

In real estate, I don't change locks, screen tenants, evict tenants, inspect properties, or finance my deals - I have property management, property inspectors, and mortgage lenders that do this for me (outsourcing).

So, what is your loan size? 

Hi @Tyler Koller I've used apartments.co for screening and rent collection in the past and it worked well.