I have been in residential construction for some time and know very few reputable companies that would guarantee a 60 day build on anything close to 4500 sq ft.

This guy has got to be one SMOOTH LOVER to disappear 93% of your investment and have you worried about his reputation. 

This is just slimy and is what gives real estate a bad reputation.

People hire you for your experience, reputation, and connections.

Take photos of all damages, keep copies of all incident reports and communication records with your tenants, fire department, and insurance company.I would strongly consider working with a reputable public adjuster, especially for a claim of this size.

There are some reputable hard money lenders and a lot of disreputable ones, but you are going to need to layout your plan and resources.

Anyone know anyone in that area that is reputable?

If they continually kill deals they will get a reputation and the Realtor referrals will dry up and they will have little work.

We're eager to get it rented out as soon as possible and would appreciate any recommendations for reputable property management companies in the area.Thank you in advance for your help!

I don't want to go to a company like h&r block, but none of the indie people have reviews or reputations.