It required an extensive reno which exposed me to hours under the sink and supervision of multiple subs and tradesmen.

You aren't factoring in property management which would be another $260.  

The answer to this question depends on a number of factors that are specific to your situation.

If you move a sewer stack you'll have roof repairs to factor in as well. 

As long as you factor the higher interest rates (they are short term of course) into your initial calcs before you close the house.

I've spoken to my CPA and -- cutting to the chase and factoring in passive losses, etc -- if I were to 1031 it into different investments, I'd need to spend about $100K of equity against about $300K of debit (for a total of $400K) in order to qualify for a "like" property and avoid capital gains.What I'm looking for are thoughts on the best strategies moving forward. 

offstreet parking is a critical factor in the neighborhood.

With lower income tenants with kids, I'm sure they also want their kids to go to good schools, but that is not always the most important factor.  

OCC’S CURRY WARNS BANKS EXPOSED TO “FROTH” IN MULTIFAMILY MARKET, DISCUSSES FINTECH.Reuters (5/16, Lambert, Crimmins) reports that on Monday Comptroller of the Currency Thomas Curry spoke before the Reuters Financial Regulation Summit, warning that credit risk is growing in the CRE market, with some banks exposed to “froth” in the apartment markets in certain cities.

As you do, take notes, and I suggest that before you do another investment, have a plan for dealing with the taxation.In every deal I have ever done, taxation was one of the three or four decision factors for buying, selling, holding, etc.