I know it is too late at this point but should you find yourself in this position in the future I would utilize the 1031 exchange option.

Dividing it up into 17 acre lots would be an option as well.

If you plan to use a third option, look there as well. 

Mom and pop NY brokerages would be a better option, but they will have no training or systems, but will hold your license while you look.

I just don't see a big enough difference between the RentRedi and all of the other free softwares to justify spending $9/month.Long story short: Why should I use RentRedi compared to the free options out there?

But I'm open to other options.

Since you're selling 8 SFRs, this could break up into multiple distinct exchanges (most likely), but you have the option of combining multiple sales into single exchange purchases. 

@Autumn KimNot a bad niche if you like pain and have staying power; this is not a strategy for a hands off investor that likes excel and internet research.  

The self serve option is hit or miss, I wouldn't use it in a city with strong squatters rights.

Do I have any other options?