Quote from @Michael Soukup: Yes, I recommend you pay off all your debt first before investing in another property.

The only reason I've heard of Morris Illinois, is beacuse our family used to drive to central Illinois to camp and boat, and Morris is directly on Route 47.Are you currently investing in Chicago or near you in Joilet Account Closed?

In Mexico, as you know, when you rent to visitors, you generally don't do LTR.

There's a good chance the issue(s) you face has already been discussed and answered.Ask questions in the appropriate forum.

It could be found in any market.

In any area the quotes should all be within 5-15% of each other.

Currently my credit score is in the 800's - any thoughts? 

Several of my STR investor clients here in Colorado have used a designer, and they generally pick a few statement pieces that they spend money on and then go with FB marketplace  or even IKEA for smaller items. 

Rarely are they in decent condition.

maybe once in a while / once every few months, something will hit that would work.