(I have done initial interviews with them, but, of course, there nice and responsive initially, but later on, they show their true colors...)

You can always call back and offer more later right? 

Your numbers above for purchase price and comparable value 5 years later are suspect to me. 16,000 in appreciation over a 5 year period is equivalent to an average of less than 2% a year appreciation. 

I'd hate to look back at this deal at a later date and realize I only did it for convenience reasons.

We bought the house almost 3 years ago and not long after purchase, we noticed that the floor started buckling and later popped.

Can I call you later this week? 

I made an urgent request to obtain a duplicate key to the common area (note that this key is required to be able to enter my condo unit), and the property manager has not delivered the keys 7 days later, in spite of letting him know this is urgent.

@Mike KalobI was originally told a similar thing by my insurance agent (Liberty Mutual) but he later said I was good to add more policies. 

Years later you can move upstairs and eventually exit the property and rent top and bottom, then refinance to buy another property.

The couple moved into the fully furnished home in 2012, and 2 years later they sensed something just wasn’t right.