The toilet also worked perfectly, this crack did not even affect the functionality or need to buy new parts for the entire toilet ($400) and then the installation ($400)-$2700 because he claimed oil leaks on driveway were from us, but in the letter of itemized damages withheld from our deposit, he told us he "verbally instructed" us to park our cars off the driveway (which i don't remember him doing) BUT in the lease he says "“Tenant parking may be reassigned another on site/on premises area of the property at the discretion of the landlord, and any such assignment shall be issued in writing and & shall become effective immediately upon receipt of written notice to Tenants from Landlord.” which he never told us in writing, and he probably does not have proof indicating it was us.-$100 per hole and $50 for paint to repair two quarter sized holes on the stairway for removing a gate we have never even seen on the property or knew existed (he is telling us we caused the holes by removing this gate) if anything, we wanted a gate for the dog and would have never removed it. but we seriously never knew of this gate ever existing, never mind removed it.-$350 for removal and disposal of broken toilet, remove and disposal of oil and clean up materials, and storage of items (trash left out for trash pick up day on the CURBSIDE that "interfered with his storage at the property")Basically, we have done nothing since receiving the letter on August 12.

The only scenario that I can see would be if a tenant filed a claim for loss due to damage that was caused by the property, e.g. a pipe leaked into their television. 

Got a slow leak under the sink you did not notice? 

A client of mine is closing on a triplex in Dunedin/North Clearwater on the 31st but there is some work to be done including some moisture behind drywall, minor repairs, and will eventually need a rehab on 2 of the bathrooms, floors, paint, and perhaps a kitchen or 2 and we need a contractor (or at least a plumber) to take a look and give us a quote to repair and the options/severity of the leak. 

Well, when they finally install the sink it leaked and damaged the base cabinet..

She texts me one day saying the sink is leaking and there is water everywhere.

When in closing of the house a gas leak on the water heater had to be repaired for the house to meet FHA regulations so my realestate agent said they would get a verbal confirmation from the owner and selling agent that it would be fixed so that we did not need to reprint and sign new contracts.

Leaking freon under the house in lines.

It's a brand of paint that is designed to be non-porous, so odors don't leak out from the underlying material.  

There is also work that he is claiming that was either done badly, or that he did not do at all ex: hanging lights, and roof done ended up leaking.