You have a strong seller's market and there is never a guarantee that appreciation will be uniform so it may not be a good idea to hold. 

You can also check with @Dave Foster he is who I send all of my clients to.

Seems to come with its strong advantages.

I know that I’m not a major client, but maybe, just maybe they are stretched too thin.

I always volunteer to manage our clients purchases in person when they buy in the USVI :)But just like you can sell any where in the US and buy anywhere in the US - You can also sell any type of investment real estate and buy any other type of investment real estate. 

It has saved the day for several my clients during pandemic.Bob Collett

But here's where it gets truly electrifying: our savvy client is seizing the reins on a remarkable 10-year tax abatement, already one year in, opening the door to a decade of substantial savings.

Transitioning from the NFL to real estate is an impressive pivot, and diving into fix-and-flips is a great strategy for building a strong investment portfolio.

sounds like you are off to a strong start. 

We have a client who was also an active investor who is selling off their portfolio.