But I heard a lot of bad reviews about property management companies.

I found an amazing title company and was able to double close on the deal.

The postings created by a property management company will likely include the property management company's information in the description (they may even have their name watermarked on all of the listing photos).

Assess how your property managers are performing and make a decision on whether you should handle property management yourself or enlist the help of a professional management company.

Contact several local property management companies, they should tell you a conservative and accurate rental amount.

Hey Mike, did you manage to find an insurance company for your str?

Nate,I would recommend speaking to an Independent Agent that represents multiple companies. 

Ask if they have "clear title", meaning has the title commitment/report come back from the title company with no issues for seller to fix/resolve. 

If not, a management company would essentially kill any margin you were making.

Do you have a title company you work with regularly in Tampa?