So just be ready for that hurdle and link up with someone knowledgeable that can help you through that process.

I appreciate any time you take to add knowledge to this newbie here.

That's a good start while you have W-2 income, and it will start you developing a knowledge base for managing a property and also start creating a track record of your performance.

Andrew, there are several very knowledgeable accountants here on BiggerPocekts who are experienced with REI.

Quick edit to ad I have checked the bigger pockets directory for HML, but I’m still looking for recommendations for local lenders willing to work with a new but knowledgeable investor.

I think if you have "boots on the ground" in place in NY and/or don't mind making the trip then you should take advantage of your knowledge of the local market.I am not sure where you are getting your list of apartment owners from, but I typically use a cheap postcard on my first mailer to "scrub the list". 

I didn't get past the first call before picking mine, as the Realtor I spoke with sounded like a wealth of knowledge mixed with incredible interpersonal and negotiation skills. 

@Dave Foster is a wealth of knowledge... lives and breathes this.

Sorry I am not more knowledgeable on the subject- I use a local CPA, Deweese & Associates and she takes care of it for us.TristanP.S.

You seem to be extremely knowledgeable on the multi family sector!