If these areas are stellar, the incident may have been an unusual occurrence. 

They are the codes you operate your business by.Also you should be aware that when starting out if you are uncertain how to deal with tenants and are uncertain as to how to implement practices due to personal emotional conflicts you would be advised to hire a property manager. 

Do you share your criteria for acceptance and is anything especially high or unusual?  

I only meant to make the point that unusual animals can be companion animals.

., I have suspicions that she faked a LL reference because the previous LL has the same unusual German surname as her boyfriend.

Stuff like that is not unusual for him, and does not even raise an eye brow.

It's unusual in Ohio to see a ceiling smooth.  

The only thing I was considering reporting was the fact that it was a very strange interaction and highly unusual that someone would respond in the way that he did.

This is an unusual house.

Also, this situation is so unusual that I can just about guarantee you've omitted some fact that appears innocuous but an attorney would find very relevant.