Double check any cap ex you might have coming in the next year or more there so you can plan to set that aside (boilers, roofs, etc).

The initial thought is you are probably charging too much if no one is interested, or your photos or description are bad.Four beds and only one bath probably reduces demand as well, that’s potentially a lot of people sharing one toilet.And it is winter - I’m in Buffalo, I hate listing rentals this time of year.

To beat 5.25% mortgage rate....the corresponding, offsetting stock market return would be at least double that...To answer your question requires (1) knowing what risk adjusted return you will be able to earn in the future (2) knowing what interest rates will do in the future.  

There could be a "double whammy", a recession (which we seem overdue for) then a drop in interest rates which leads to a big influx of new housing supply. 

Investment Info:
Single-family residence buy & hold investment.

Purchase price: $140,000 in Nov. 2005

Sale price: $175,000 in July 2007
1872 square foot single family home with no garage. Nice f...

Is it a typical inn/bed and breakfast setup with all the rooms inside of a main house? 

However, planes of that era couldn’t stay aloft on one engine for long, doubling the risk of crashing into the Atlantic Ocean without any added benefit.

Quote from @Kegan Scholl: -22 years old-$50,000 pre tax income from business this year-80k in savings-30k in investments-pre approved for $350,000 (had to use parents as co-signers because I started business 2 years ago and didn’t make much first year)Looking to get into first house by house hacking a 4 bed 2 bath renting out 3 rooms.

I'd like to fund larger amounts like double closings.

Nearly doubled my money!