There is a single family home that was divided and one half has been rented and an ad on small "house" that has also been rented mostly long term.

How do you pull annual reports in Rent Redi?  

But in general, your biggest risks are not necessarily what's the maximum rent you can get, but can you find a reliable tenant that will always pay and pay on-time.

Renting in NYC adds risk. 

Note the property tax will be -10% on the rent by itself.Month 0 to 24: $2450 * 0.5 - $1573 =-$348/monthMonth 24 to 60: $2450 * 0.5 - $1541 =-$316/monthNext issue is due to the low leverage starting at month 24, the ROI takes a beating.  

Speaking with the seller's agent, all the tenants are current on rents and pay rents on time.

They change jobs more frequently so renting a room works better for their lifestyles. 

Started renting it out in Summer of '24 when I first moved!

Buying a large new build home can also work well as a house hack as you can charge a premium rent, and generally most bedrooms built now a days have en suites (at least in my market).  

And assuming you get the tenant out (or get them to pay rent), are those the rents you'd get AFTER the rehab?