I received an inquiry from someone whose account was a few years old but didn't have a profile picture or any reviews and the only item verified was a phone number.

If that does not help, I would wait another month and order the credit reports again, because sometimes it takes longer for the inquiry/late payment/missed payment/collection to show up.  

Hey thanks for responding to my inquiry Charlie and Wayne.

I posted one of my REO properties on CL, got a HUGE responce , 5-10 inquiries within a week.

Sucks.As for your inquiry maybe I can help you out. 

This case (first one I looked at) was dismissed, but keep in mind there was someone bringing an action to cause this inquiry.

However my inquiry had nothing to do with determining whether or not it was a deal.I appreciate the response but allow me to clarify.

I have been receiving more calls and inquiries from my website than I know what to do with.

My other properties have rented in about one week with numerous inquiries and several applications.

List it there and within 2 days you will have more inquiries than you know what to do with.