I recommend you decide, take action, and move on. 

I have 9 properties in 2 states and 3 different counties.

New kitchen and bathroom.

We don't have kids (might in the future), my husband and I are young and healthy, have stable high-income full-time jobs, and just put in a lot of work to both properties so don't expect huge expenses in the near future.

Hi Yael, I am a featured agent from Bigger Pockets in the QC market and can assist with all of your questions.

Far more than most real estate acitivies and much quicker think about it.. you sell the same info over and over and get paid instantly you have no roofs to fix no tenants to manage etc etc.. you do have reputation management of course.

The area is rich in history and culture, and with ongoing investment and development in the neighborhood.

Harlem is undergoing a significant transformation, and properties like this one, which offer both historical significance and modern amenities, are in high demand.

I have a tenant that moved in and reported Foundation and wobbly toilet upstairs.

Quote from @Ashley Mierez: If you are looking for investors, start at 10% at least and go up from there.