@Fox Barolo first thing that jumps out is in your photo/analysis it looks like you forgot to subtract the monthly expenses noted, so your monthly net is actually going to be $700. 

I do have waffle irons, multiple coffee pots, 2 Keurigs, a wok, a bunch of skillets, etc.

Zillow is best but I advise casting a wider net.  I

It was the size of a quarter and was from where my wife had a potted plant.

Time is more valuable.STR is a good deal if owner does Turns and manages the property directly, then all that income makes it into the pot. 

For example, say your goal is to do flips; a cash-out refinance might be better because you can take that money out and have a pot of money to deploy and not have to worry about the high fees of hard money or having to stick to a lender’s draw schedule, giving you more flexibility.

I believe every state still has a large pot of money and they're working hard to give it away.

Hi Micheal,If it were mine.HUD gives a 15 year service life for cabinet tops.For instance if the age is 10 years, meaning 5 years (33.3%) of the service life leftI would charge for 33.3% of the cost of the replacement (parts and labor) that I had to write a check for.Owner labor is typically not billed, because you don't cut yourself a check for the labor.Make a point of telling new renters not to put hot pots or irons on the new surface (they probably didn't know any better).Here is a service life list for you.  

It is more important that you have a fully stocked kitchen with a cookie sheet and a crock pot than a cool painting.

There are a lot of hands in the pot and the management company is very very important.