If you've chosen these two just because you like the Indy market, I'd recommend expanding your search to other markets and focusing on reputation and customer service/PM quality.

She had since graduated and had sufficient verifiable income and approved her.If a similarly qualified tenant without an eviction had also applied then we would have chosen the tenant with the cleaner record, but it wasn't an automatic deal breaker for us and she's worked out just fine.

She sent me another text today saying "I'm sorry you have chosen this route.

If you think you've chosen the wrong place to live, we'll gladly let you give notice to move out (insert date)."

Every single time it equates to the fact that the tenant has chosen to spend his rent money on something he feels is more important.

In your ad, say you will process the emails in the order received and the senders will be notified to fill out an application, if a renter was not chosen from the people ahead of them in line.  

Getting tenants you have chosen yourself, who are people who responded to your ad and rented your unit because they thought it was a fair price, etc., is so much more pleasant.And, as you say, how do you choose which one gets kicked out?

Of course, if you do that, your yield will drop precipitously- in fact, if you tried it in my hometown(New York City,) you'd have a negative cash flow, as the rent rate wouldn't cover the mortgage expenses and taxes.What you've chosen to do, and please correct me if I'm wrong, is purchase B and C residential, and rent to those who are frequently unable to buy a home of their own.

I have chosen white maple cabinets with granite so far but i would like some input before making the final sale.

If they withdrew their application, send them a follow-up letter thanking them for their interest in the property at ___________ and that this letter is to acknowledge that you understand they have chosen to withdraw their application as of _________ (date).If they did not officially withdraw their application, then @Steve Babiak is correct about the need for a rejection letter.