My numbers look pretty much identical to yours.

I would not rely on bank statements solely, as I have seen cases where the money was in the account one day, and gone the next due to gambling problems or identity theft issues.

Maybe their identity is extremely tied to what they do and less about who they are as a person. 

Rational people would tell the seller they are identical.

The Fair Housing Act - which applies to private landlords too - makes 'it is illegal to discriminate in housing on the basis of a person's race, color, national origin, religion, sex (incuding gender identity and sexual orientation), familial status, or disability." 

To work with our company we do a soft pull to verify identity.

This addresses @Jack Tucker 's comments about how to grow as a turn-key operator without messing up.Our Cleveland guy didn't know how to do that (I'll call him Bill to protect his identity).

I figured if I found two nearly identical houses, I could get an idea.

@Joshua Messinger @David LemontThat's actually a great benefit of that resort, all of the units are identical and controlled by the in-house management team to allow each individual unit to have the exact same occupancy rates, pricing, and therefore overall income generationPersonally, in my opinion, if you were 100% limited to the $350,000 purchase price, your best bet would be to go ahead and get into the market with the condo option, rather than purchasing a relatively substandard and low-demand SFH that's likely to lose money long term at that price point

For instance, let's say I had two identical houses in every way except sqft.