I wouldn't want someone else to read my post and follow a failing pattern!

You need some sort of tile or waterproof sheets going up the walls to the ceiling.

Denver has been a very solid market over the last 10 years and looks to continue the trend as migratory patterns continue to head that direction. 

Too much trouble to reset that flange, you'd have to jackhammer up the floor and all that tile...Just get a 14" toilet.

To build on what Scott said, since this has already happened once, if it ever happenes again with this tenant and God forbid she hurts someone, you may be found culpable since you were aware of this "pattern."

I have pretty much all of the skills to do the renovations sheetrock, tile, etc.

I had sewer backing up into a basement and sure enough the city had done work with heavy equipment and crushed the old tile line.

Property manager recommends Porcelain Tile (states more durable in long term) over luxury vinyl tile/plank.  

Interior work included refinishing hardwood floors, painting, laying new tile, and installing new light fixtures.

Are these units section 8 quality, or are these units being dolled up with stone countertops and lvp floors instead of sanded hardwood floors or Armstrong 12 by 12 tiles.