There's always some bad apples in any bunch but for vast majority, it's a win-win. 

Did you keep some coverage in case of major lawsuits? 

All the cheap properties are MAJOR fixer-uppers with no Rent Zestimates - probably because there are not enough rental data points.This one is priced at $135k with only $1,152 Rent Zestimate.

That’s a major concern.

@Scott Goulet if that's the case and there is no significant difference in occupancy, then my gut tells me that it is not a major factor that guests consider and are willing to pay a premium for.

Pittsburgh is home to many major universities including the rapidly growing Carnegie Mellon University which is “at least partially responsible for Pittsburgh’s growth, from revitalized neighborhoods to a vibrant and booming restaurant scene.”

However, it is an old home and you are thinking about major cosmetic upgrades too.    

The market has been growing in terms of population, jobs and, major companies moving here like Intel, Google, Meta, etc. 

However, for major issues, STR insurance ensures you're fully covered.

Until that happens, enjoy major cash flow.