They didn’t like that we referred to the land behind our property as a “wooded area” because it’s their private property and we are “falsely advertising” and “encouraging guests to trespass.”

Knowing you are remote and powerless a lot of companies will just throw out an absurd number and risk you walking away because enough people will just agree to it. 

To think your property or rental is now a bad investment is likely false or limiting belief.One aspect, now you don't have to estimate rent, just raise it 3% every year!

Read posts on RTO and Dodd-Frank, also, look up IRS depreciation rules, reporting requirements and what filing false returns gets you.

Its absolutely absurd.

Insurances said rebuild costs were over 800k (Which is absurd, its nowhere near that much, maybe 250k) Its also in a better section of the area. 

"Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities.Voltaire

Of course, consult some qualified professionals.Of course, be sure and cognizant why you want LLC's and what it takes to operate them, otherwise its both a moot endeavour and false sense of security.To economize on effort and costs, many will put a "bunch" of properties into one LLC. 

This creates the false impression that by paying an extra $60 a month that you will cut your loan in half. 

The owners, like you, went the eviction route and the scammers had the nerve to countersue the owner claiming it was unsafe, the property was falsely advertised/presented, and that they were discriminated against.