Here’s what Zillow shows:Credit score is about 640one time payments: 81%total debt $15k open accounts are all student loans which has a note that says dispute resolved - consumer disagrees. 

That's one thing they've got down pat and the judge and bar association is 100% behind them.Best of luck getting this resolved one way or the other.

So I will pay an extra 20 or 30 a month to use a local company with very high service where immediately someone in their office answers the phone and my issue or scheduling is resolved in a few minutes.

Not all of them are compatible!

The key is to be comfortable with issues that may arise and understand that it may happen and that the team you work with reacts quickly to resolving these issues. 

You lead the call explaining that you run lists and know these are wrong all the time (so you don't make them feel bad to start), but this list said their may have been a list pendens filed at some point and it probably got resolved, but you wanted to check.

Can you please advise me on what to do next or what constructive steps I can take to resolve this. 

Of course not, I have 25k in reno, and it DOES comp at about 120k, and will rent for 1600.  2nd YES, most wholesalers are clueless not a clue what they are selling.

I invested way too many hours trying to resolve.

@Lucas Hunt50/50 is not uncommon - but also partners breaking up is also highly likely so what I would recommend is in the company operating agreement or in some type of agreement make sure you went through all the what ifs that could happen and how they would be resolvedIt’s a lot better to resolve them now versus when their is a dispute