With police reports and tickets from police you have evidence from disinterested 3rd party as to the lease violation as opposed to a complaint from a neighbor that nobody can verify.

If you or anyone else has personal experience with quantifiable evidence of successfully owning a small or medium size business on an absentee/passive basis I would be interested in learning about it.  

Evidently current market sales, rents, and costs of properties comparable to the subject support a value 25% higher than the selling price of the subject.

I could be wrong about the title company but title companys are pretty evident when you try to find them on line. 

Look for well-documented processes and continuous improvement evidence to identify potential bottlenecks.Market and Demand AnalysisUnderstand market conditions and future demand projections by analyzing market size, growth trends, and competitive landscape.

Once you have all the evidence gathered, submit the tenant to collections and maybe you'll get some of it back, but don't count on it.

However, during the inspection of the home, the inspector found evidence that there had been a fire.

seems to be credible evidence that this Vendor should not be allowed on your site.. 

I use online methods for payments, but recently I noticed Zelle records were absent and this placed both myself and my tenent in distress, as we no longer had evidence of a deposit. 

I have other evidence he is not doing well looking after the pool anyway so "scr3w it...all three are coming out".