As others have said it might not be fruitful to go after the insurance companies but seems like they are just trying to get out of making good on their policies.

They will go after the low-hanging fruit. 

Overall I view SFH investing as much higher risk, all your eggs in one basket, and therefor the "potential" reward less attractive. 

In fact, If you’re someone who rents out but doesn’t feel a duty to your residents to care for their good and actively works for it, then you (in my opinion) don’t deserve the fruits of REI. 

As a first time buyer I don’t want to put all my eggs in one basket with a broker, although I’m certain they are trying their best and will eventually find a property.

It had some low-hanging fruit opportunities (like many of the leases that have not been updated for 10 years!)

I’ve gots ground STR business. A few years ago I had about 40% of my bookings coming from VRBO but airBnB gained significant traction, and soon 95% of my bookings  were from AirBnB with a 90% occupancy rate. Sounds go...

You can definitely do better, but this is the low hanging fruit normal I have witnessed on the buy and sell side of transactions.   

Wouldn't it be better to spread your funds out over multiple properties instead of putting all of your eggs in one basket? 

I think now as this is bearing fruit The Next Step would be to get the names of the 100 plus other investors in this complex that were sold these properties.