Hi all,Here's a scenario my fiancee and I are in.

Are you from the US or are you here on visa?

I lived there for a full two years, and then I moved to Chicago to be with my gf/fiancee.

He's been around the proverbial block vis a vis Buffalo housing idiosyncrasies....

I'm worried about, in the event of an eviction, how would the sheriff be told to only evict the tenant in the in-law suite, not the tenant in the main house, or visa-versa, when there is only one address? 

@David Tipton  you are absolutely correct on the single member LLC. vis a vi the corp veil.. one reason to have proper G L insurance.. on my 27 homes subdivision I am building in Portland right now.... it cost me 40k for  1 million in coverage for the 10 year warrenty period. and we bought that basically only for cost of defense.I am just about out of the land lording game.. and can only go on my 30 plus years of owning the dog gone things.. and I have never been sued by a tenant. 

@James ShippGenerally, C-corporations are better for raising commercial credit (visa, mastercard, amex, etc). 

The obvious problem here is that I am not a US citizen or hold any visa of some sort. 

Our mother lived in the apartment for 17, when she moved out sister used a broker to find tenants (when they had to leave - student visa expired) she used another broker to find new tenants who have been a nightmare.

I believe you are fortunate to have a fiancee who is in the military who can relate to your military( air force) background, your travels to various countries, your real estate experience with Sean as a mentor, and the foresight to join Bigger Pockets.Take advantage of resources Bigger Pockets has to offer such as: ebooks, blogs, forums, webinars, podcasts, keyword alerts, learn section, informative people in many fields of real estate, colleagues, and more.