If not, you could focus on other selling points, like the acreage or future ADU potential, but a garage would probably make the property more competitive.

With hopes to build two additional cabins in the future.

Yes, I realize it was the first time, that is why I would cover the cost in an effort to be a good landlord and not discourage my tenants from reporting future issues.

They are about to move out and I’m nervous to rent to a stranger in the future with this same policy.

With no comps in the area for new construction and the highest rehab selling for 205k, building enough at the onset, 4-6 new construction homes, may be the only way to start a neighborhood turn.The city is looking to increase density in the area and add anchor points in near the area to cater to future investment. 

And I hope that is more future readers of this post, and on BP. 

Most STR markets have seasonality, and there are untold issues in the future that will effect cashflow. 

For future reference, what @Charles Carillo said is very good advice.

Emphasize how this arrangement could work to their benefit, offering steady income, avoiding a traditional sale process, and giving them the freedom to move forward with their plans such as buying that sailboat and sailing around the world.If they ultimately decide they’re not interested in selling, you’re still in a great position to continue your search and buy your own property in the near future.

This is critical because depending on your future goals and what we think the market is going to do, we can structure everything to keep more money in your pocket for the next deal.