I don't know the market you're investing in at all, so I'm not sure if this will affect your ability to get tenants at market rent at all but it's not an unreasonable sounding option.Best wishes!

The PM gave an estimate of $7k to $8k which is not unreasonable for a passive role but we had decided to sell.  

Don’t want to be unreasonable demanding 3k two months ahead of time but also want money up front to take the property off the market.  

It’s not unreasonable to expect the “C” home to only sell for 90% of the appraisal value because let’s face it, another investor is the most likely natural buyer for this home and will not want to pay retail unlike the “A” or “B” neighborhood where the buyer is more likely be a homeowner.In the case study I shared, once you factor in closing costs, the realized gain on the successful BRRRR yields very little gain whereas the better situated home that fails the BRRRR test performs quite well.

Anyway, I do understand where you come from and I don't think it is unreasonable.

I don’t think your numbers are too unreasonable, and for that reason I think scale is your friend if you’re looking to cover your whole housing expense.

Is there a reason why all of them mentioned this but the above users claim its unreasonable?

Their 10% fee is unreasonable when you realize that's what they're also charging your guests on average.

You just blew thousands of dollars because it was another issue or because the tenants have unreasonable expectations. 

Though again, if it were challenged the ORT which is highly biased towards tenants would likely say that was unreasonable and let them out of their legal obligation early no matter what the reason was that they broke the agreement.