Honestly, I would sell it now while there are still an endless supply of foolish newbie investors out there that have the capital to throw around $2M with no underwriting skills and assume they'll cashflow based on bad advice from realtors and youtubers.Eventually once everyone starts wisening up to these investment-only properties being a negative investment, prices will start falling and you might lose that equity. 

Also, there were times when the appraisal came back lower and the refinance did not make sense and he did not throw a tantrum and say we wasted his time, etc.

Examples of pitfalls include purchasing in an undesirable area, not understanding the market values (vs. list prices), not knowing the rental values (current and market), inheriting bad tenants, buying a lemon, going rogue on renting and management with no contacts / systems / no legal understanding of PA and Municipal landlord-tenant laws, not having trusted resources and contractors in place, using out of state lenders or shaky financing, throwing lipstick on a pig when renovating a house and wondering why it's ARV isn't increasing, tenants are renting, etc.

Just throwing a ping pong table on a concrete slab in the garage is marginal.I had an STR buyer in Conifer, in the mountains outside of Denver, turn a massive unfinished walk-in closet into a little arcade area with two comfy lounge chairs and two vintage arcade games.

Most preachers will tell you that we are under the age of grace with a new covenant but oddly enough they never throw out the mosaic law of tithe .

Throw money burning in the wind paying for your second appraisal.

I have found that the best answer for YOU is what will allow you to sleep well on your pillow at night without thinking too much about it.

Just want to throw my opinion in on your carpet.

This is the perfect example.We have been using the leses and other froms from WLB for over a decade and I have seen them getting updated over the years, so I somtimes throw out a package of forms and order new ones to be up to date, but they are so inexpensive, its a no brainer.WLB has a store downtown Milwaukee worth visiting: they have all sorts of landlord supplies you did not even know you needed from print all the way to parking signs and traffic cones.

We don't throw away new carpet just because one prospective resident doesn't like it.