See if he will stay on after the sale helping you to manage remember when he sells he looses his identity. 

Each one has been nearly identical, 3 bed 2 bath on each side 2600 sq ft total.

If you were to create two identical houses and placed one on a 5k square foot lot on the side of a hill and the other on a flat, 10k square foot corner lot, do you really expect them to sell for the same price?

Now you just got your identity stolen.Talk with local people or companies that you know are national and come recommended by others.

I've noticed several identical post over the last week.  

Perhaps they are just phishing for personal data of your borrowers for identity theft and tax refund scams...?

Sometimes you will buy two identical properties in similar neighborhoods and have different results or even have the same property perform differently over time.

Each uses different technology too, so even with two that have identical features, one might just feel better to you.  

Why, because each individual agent that sends me stuff is identical to the other.

Milwaukee is very unique in that it is a city of neighborhoods, with each neighborhood holding on to its unique identity due to the people who live there.