The suit claims that by renting out the property as a short-term rental has unreasonably interfered with Rossi’s use and enjoyment of his home over an extended period of time – even to the point of preventing him and his wife from using their backyard and being awakened at 2 a.m."

They think my area is cheap money compared to other areas and falsely assume they can BRRRR and raise rents unreasonably high and still find tenants.

It is unreasonable to expect Landlords to continue to not collect rent and have no viable recourse.  

This will be a costly leaning experience for you.In the meantime, don't do anything radical, unreasonable or extrajudicial.  

If you need a license to do a $20 hair cut, how is it unreasonable for hundred thousand dollar real estate transactions? 

Consequentially, once rates calm down its not unreasonable to expect the rental rates to decrease as well.

So I don't think it's unreasonable to request a minimum of consideration from guests.

So is his request unreasonable?

Arcadia is a neighborhood where sf family home easily can be 1m plus so getting doors at 250k doesn’t seem unreasonable.

ARV will tell you whether this is a reasonable venture or an unreasonable one.