Identical layout, wall-unit for A/C, super boxy cookie-cutter look, originally intended to be sold as a package deal of 5 properties (so it makes sense previous owner would slap down two manufactured homes for extra income), etc. 

say A and B are essentially identical neighboring properties but B has a 80% LTV mortgage on it so its costs are say 70% higher than A. 

It's not a 'want', it's a 'must'...it's part of your identity.

If someone told me that I would have 10 identical groups of applicants applying, and only one group of the bunch was bad, I would tell them to reject all 10 groups and keep fishing. 

Rape and murder seem more serious than petty theft from a supermarket, but we still pursue charges for the latter. 

Side benefit- ID theft policy included for the $29 feeBest of luck

But yet, I can send him something absolutely identical, with nearly duplicate financials, and he won't even budge, let alone make an offer. 

If that is correct, then if I have 2 identical properties next to each other on the same street, in the same condition, shouldn't they be the same cap rate?

I plan on doing the rehab myself with the help of family and friends for about $10-15k.Here's where it gets fun:The house across the street on an almost identical footprint sold at 332k last summer.

-Electric & Heat: These numbers are identical?