Question is, should I go ahead and sell off all the properties now while I am still have a job and sell will be reflected on 2024 Taxes, them 0 income next 3 years.

Stuart you bring up a point that reflects a whole subject that’s a topic onto itself.  

If the leases are under market, it is your responsibility to reflect that in the your offer.

The price reflect expected rent appreciation.  

Had your bet been more "correct," the tenant buyers would have walked into little or no appreciation as the option price at the time of exercise would have reflected the true market price. 

Now I believe there is a fee in order to have them come a 3rd time 🙄.Both properties have already gained in value according to RedFin, not sure if that would reflect if they were sold but its a positive move.

Price reflects all of these attributes.

However, after reflection, I realized I was becoming too emotionally attached to my first investment after a 15-year break and faced challenges finding reliable contractors.Update (5/17/23):After three failed contractor attempts, I finally secured a reliable one.

And you finally take title to the property at the purchase price reflecting both the existing structure and the ADU. 

Digging into the history of the property will usually tell you that the name was recently changed to reflect that.