I talked to 2 property management companies who I should rent the house out to one tenant/one household (e.g a couple or family).

You're still missing the fact that median income: household ratio was completely different back then and the overall price of living in all other metrics are significantly and disproportionately higher than the 90s and early 2000s.

However, the management of tenants are more and possibility of conflicts could be higher.As for renting the whole house, rents would definitely be lower, since not many household or single individuals can afford paying for the whole house, so most likely you will be attracting a family with children.

Household debt has hit a record high, rising to $17.69 trillion in the first quarter of 2024, with credit card debt alone averaging $6,360 per borrower, per CNBC.

and I think household formation in the US is going to continue along briskly for the next 15-25 years even if population growth slows. with that said I'm buying stocks too. 

Pigeon Forge is as recession-proof as an area can be due to its close proximity to half of the US households, meaning 1 day's travel to get here so I can only imagine what other tourist areas are feeling.Besides our STRs, we also have a 94 key motel, and reservations for it are down also, right now more comparable to our 2021 figures.The last couple of years have spoiled us with revenue figures for sure.

Market DynamicsIs the median household income approximately three times the forecasted rent?

3) Where can I find accurate market data such as school system ratings, population growth, median household income, and crime rates for specific neighborhoods in Orlando?

That is a beautiful thing for a single income household but is nowhere near enough to reach the financial security and lifestyle I would like for my family. 

Moving forward we are exploring possibly combing households due to the large size of the property and the difficulty of upkeep but there are several questions/ issues that need to be addressed so it does not put either of us in a compromised position.When her husband died a friend paid off her mortgage due to it going into foreclosure ( 210k total).