It sounds like you are taking all the risk and they are doing what a normal property management company would do.

The real estate guru's will tell you that you should call the credit card companies (3 separate companies) who offer the 0% APR and request to get the maximum amounts on all three.  

Does anyone have experience with either company?

First off, you should know that getting a loan as a foreigner in Mexico is quite difficult—most traditional lending options aren’t available, so you’ll likely have to explore alternative financing or fund the construction yourself.When it comes to managing the property as a short-term rental, you'll need to decide whether you want to open a small company in Mexico.

Especially, when you add the other companies Zillow owns - Hotpads and Trulia.FB Marketplace is almost a waste of time in our Metro Detroit market as 95+% of inquires we never hear back from.

Quote from @John Mason: Christian this may help give more perspectiveshttps://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/925/topics/1145785-begi...Also maybe a good idea to touch base with Property Management companies and Realtors whodo MTR placements, I know that you have to pay them a  fee but 85 %  is better than 0% , am I right?  

So, while their insurance company covered us, it didn't cover the owner!

So we moved forward with the claim and a mitigation company to address the damage. 

The 4 I've talked to are: Blue Gate Capital, Easy Street, Bombora, and Mortgage Calculator Company. 

Networking with other investors at local REIA is a great way to do that and also a great way to meet realtors, wholesalers, contractors, inspectors, property management companies and anything in between.