My managment company has made more than a reasonable amount of attempts to get the HOA to have this repaired. 

I would focus on a strategy and you and your brother like (Do you want day to day management of a house flip?

If there is a property manager, your success rate is going to be very low.   

@Micah Huffman unless you are going to commit to learning some basics about being a landlord AND are willing to commit at least 2-4 hours each month managing a Property Management Company - it's probably best you sell.Otherwise, it's highly likely you could lose more due to bad tenants and management.

Managing a rental property can be challenging, especially if it’s your first experience.

Know this: the #1 reason why landlords fail - failure to manage to the lease (source:  American Apartment Owners' Assn). 

Try interviewing at least three managers.1.

At the time QB was not the best for property management.

Property management vs. self-managing:Self-managing—at least in the beginning—can be invaluable.

Does anyone know of a dscr lender that will allow for seasoned money for a down payment and a really good property manager in Ohio specifically in Columbus, Cin, and Cleveland?