Too many people think an LLC is some magical device to insure them against the most unlikeliest of incidents.

This incident will be handled on the lowest level.

During a slip and fall incident if a renter sues me, as soon as I get the legal notice can I move my property to LLC or is it too late even then?

That neighborhood had all burglary and larceny incidents at a bit higher rate than other areas of University City, with relatively few of those occurring on Ursula ave.  

Remind her to follow up with the police about the incident and check with the department to see if your tenet can get on a patrol list.

Some will care of nature of incident, others will be indifferent.We've gotten into a property that had a suicide by hanging in the garage and the next buyer felt it had nothing to do with them and didn't blink.Plan extra padding in your budget for worse case scenarios.

Idaho's privacy laws stipulated a $1,000 fine per incident (I think that it was interpreted to me as meaning per call or piece of mail) if convicted.

That can be caused by presence of black mold. https://www.moldsafesolutions.com/mold-rage/Do nothing immediately but if they report similar incidents again and again,  or the next tenant also reports something similar, it may be a time to explore this angle (instead of calling the ghost busters ) !!

But after this incident we informed the tenant the dog had to be secured at all times. 

This morning I called my insurance agent, he was most cooperative, he called the local police to get a case number and said this is by now a famous incident!