Happy to talk further on the area (we are large enough to offer options to focus on student rentals/UW Madison campus, and anything from Class C to A locations or suburban/surrounding communities) but to help you consider broad initial search, you could start by deciding how important cash flow is. 

I would rent or sell that condo and buy a duplex in a class A or B location in KC.

Do you provide move in and move out reports How many pictures do you take of the property prior to tenant moves in and after the tenant moves outDo you get weekly reports when the property is vacant what prospective tenants are saying about your homeDo you provide monthly newsletters to your tenantsDo you hold investor education classes to help me become a better investorDo you have single point portfolio based management services?

This figure is for C class properties.  

That said, I’ve found that properties in C-class neighborhoods tend to perform best with Section 8 tenants.

That would almost always be from the same lender who has a 1st AND 2nd on the property and they are just fed up with the owner and are taking the opportunity to get out of a bad situation entirely.Sorry, it's complex enough that it isn't a 15 minute class.

For example if you were to exit a new build in 5 years there may be no cap ex cost (i can think of few cap ex items that does not last 5 years - maybe carpet in class c and lower), just maintenance costs which would be fairly small.Best wishes

Consider using DSCR loans- Cash flow of the property is considered in lieu of your income3.Consider purchasing in a different asset class (Large multifamily) where borrowing will be a function o fthe property income, not yours

I agree with you@Jay Hinrichs that short term view is a quick way to sink a boat.

I would say maybe Class C if I could label it such.