The guest became defensive and pointed out that 7 rolls of toilet paper (12 guests over 4 days) was not sufficient (lol) and they had to buy more tp, paper towels, and trash bags.

"Let's work together to figure this out"If they get defensive or don't own up to their mistake...

The bigger story, and most telling, is the fact the Scott himself and nobody else has jumped on the defense. 

Think of it as a football game, you need to play offense and defense.

Please let us know the individual who you are alleging has robbed you, and if they have nothing to say in their defense, we can remove their account and block anyone from their IP address from trying to rejoin the website. 

This is both an offensive and a defensive tactic.

Defense they can get from China and Russia without our questioning their social and political alignments.  

Tenant shall pay Landlord reasonable attorney fees Landlord may incur in the enforcement or defense of any term in this agreement.

But the risk is that should the deal go south (check out what happened to real estate values in 2008-2012) the investors may sue you for selling an unregistered security without an exemption from registration and since you did not utilize a Reg D offering you would have no statutory defense. 

I was a prosecutor in the state of Florida for 8 years and a criminal defense attorney there for 2 years and stopped practicing over 15 years ago.