Also, betting on appreciation for a short span (2 years) sounds too risky, as there's a lot of volatility that can happen in just 2 years.

I think making a spec sheet and getting out to as many small time bankers, investment minded agents, and other investor events like a real estate meetup or real estate groups on facebook is your best bet. 

I really see Columbus Ohio as an extremely safe bet for the next 10-20 years.

I bet this the same apartment complex discussed here: https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/88/topics/340...If so, it's not a good deal at the asking price.

If you live in an area where they sell within a week, then a fast cash offer is your best bet.  

The credit union is a good bet as well since you are a member and should be able to help you out.  

A better bet would to buy a property at University of Redlands.

I thought my best bet would be to become an agent so I could learn how the real estate market works, gain capital, and most importantly create relationships with people who can show me the ropes and point me in the right direction.

Betting on what you don't know is rarely an effective strategy. 

As Ryan Dossey mentioned if you get belly to belly with them I bet you would have ended up with a few rentals if you want in the landlord game....