Some similar phone numbers and such to other short term companies that other people said were scams.

I own Granite and Pine Properties - a Direct to Seller Marketing company that focuses on giving sellers 3 selling options. https://graniteandpinere.com/My advertising is word of mouth, social media, SEO, mailers and cold callers.

(the “Company”) met to consider its Share Redemption Program.

But the real test of this company's character came with the most recent loan I tried to close with them.First, I thought the loan rate was locked, and it was not.

I imagine there is not much of a relationship with the turnkey service after the sale and I would deal with the PM and Loan company directly. 

Third party servicing company for $35/mo handle taxes, insurance, escrow, tax forms, statements etc.

The companies you will find in the lender finder section of BP are probably mostly companies as opposed to a private person like you are referring to.

Yes, they can dispute the charge and then the CC company will have to open a dispute that you will have to answer to attempt to get your money. 

Yet the payment processor is issuing the 1099-K to the property management company.

My biggest road block right now is finding a PM company.