The good thing about the houseGood monthly cash flowGood interest rateIf its a headache property, I would sellIf it doesn't have much maintenance and you have good tenants, I would keep it.If you do decide to sell, you have about $200,000 of equity which you can buy 2-4 houses with when the market is more favorable.

I would also highly recommend you set some parameters when thinking about working with non-accredited investors or if you are one and want to invest on a large deal. 

Brew City is very good for Milwaukee!!

NAR Says - Existing home sales fall to lowest level in nearly 30 years and Median housing prices rose to a record high"The National Association of Realtors released data that showed existing home sales declined to the lowest level since 1995 last year, with 4.06 million homes sold on an annual basis.Meanwhile, the median home price median home price rose to a record high of $407,500 in 2024."

Good luck!

Looks like you have some good options in front of you @Martin Phinney.

As a private homeowner a good real estate brokerage should have a list of all things useful to homeowners available to you.

It will be highly dependent on the district and licensing.

Good luck & happy investing!

Update, Michelle and Michael are still members at MAREI and still not a single complaint and I know several of our members who use them and give good reports.