I am about an hour north up in Sheboygan Falls and I have seen many mid term rentals on the market and it doesn't seem like they are getting rented out. 

It seemed that it was about a $300-400 difference in monthly rent in that market for comparable properties that allowed vs. didn't allow pets. 

Mak, Doesn't seem like a bad rate.

And it is very straightforward to file these, so I would expect it to be well within the scope of any operator sophisticated enough to pull off an owner financed deal. 

Leads that seem dead today might turn into gold tomorrow.

You seem to know the area very well. :-) 

Seems odd I cannot get a response this time, I even called there number and it goes to a woman's voicemail?

or "most properties don't seem to allow pets, but i plan to allow them, so how much do you think we can bump the rent for that?"

Indeed, the FAIR ordinance is anything but fair to non-corporate landlords, seemingly punished for investing in rental houses to generate income as an alternative to stocks and bonds.A handful of opportunists likely could learn to exploit these new rules, preying on otherwise law-abiding landlords to obtain legalized shake-down payments.

Seems like you have a good head on your shoulders.