Everything needs to be the same even the same seat mots times.

Now Person D lives in their apartment and there have been a few disputes however mot of them were handled by the tenants themselves with conversations, I only heard bout them after the fact when another issue came up.So in retrospect, I think in my case A, B, & C were both somewhat "problem" tenants, all were a bit immature and had issues having a direct conversation with a neighbor, somewhat to be expected when renting to college students in their 20's.  

Not that I am going to announce that to HOA, however, they oversee everything and I am mot sure this can become a problem.

I use Larrie Garcia, Neighborhood Realty LLCI've also heard good things about Mot-J, although I've never used them myself. 

(Long term tenant whose rent has mot increased in 15 years)Insurance and tax currently paid by owner.Needs a 30k new roof.Maint: $1600 annual365k for sales priceTax on that price would be $8600 annuallyInsurance $3400 annuallyQuestion: Should I evaluate this deal from how I would structure rents and payments? 

Others may mot be so fortunate.

When you say mot taken action yet was a good observant.