I know I can't be the only one who has had this setup before, so I am just looking for thoughts, advice, experience, etc.

Any advice is greatly appreciated.

If you do have to move because of a job, you would be safest (in my opinion, i am not giving legal advice or financial advice), i would sell that property to ensure that you did not just purchase with the goal of moving out early and taking advantage of lower rates and lower down payments for purchasing your home as a primary residence. 

Thanks for the helpful advice.

Readers should seek professional advice. 

Thanks for advice!

Any/all advice welcome. 

Strategic??

I would take James' advice: ignroe the rent, deal with the unauthorized cat, and move forward.

The forums are full of experienced investors who are happy to share advice and tips to help you succeed.Best,Jarret