(...and I need to update that profile pic as it's about 8 years old, when I was still a young 39 1/2!)

By modeling each lease, you'll be able to paint a clear picture of the risk/return profile of the investment.

I posted a rental and got a lot of responses but almost none had filled out a profile.

I list my rentals on Zillow, and I have an agent profile on there, but I dont use any of their other services. 

I suspect that as part of what is considered in doing a full blown appraisal, your overall risk profile and DSR (Debt Service Ratio) will be looked at.You have to be careful about your assumptions and ensure that the stuff you're adding to your portfolio is capable of producing the income where that looks favorable, especially if you don't have other earnings (or much of them). 

@Chris Papa  Check out my profile and hit me up..

Just having a Zillow account won't generate leads - you need to get 5 5-star ratings to boost you profile and make sure you are quick to respond to anything that does come through. 

You may find your properties right there.If you fill in your profile with experience it will help others help you better.

When it comes to tenant profile, risk, and cash flow (or lack thereof) there is so much variety within the city that it makes your head spin. 

As you can see there is no shortage of columbus agents that can help you. we posted two deals recently for two different duplexes we are trying to sell. one is in hungarian village and the other is in harrison west near the short north. check out those on the marketplace, you can find them by going to my profile and looking at recent posts.