(Unfortunately, the investor fell for this gimmick and did NOT get their own 3rd party inspections, appraisals or even visit the properties they were buying, against our best efforts to encourage proper due diligence and follow our check list for their own protection.)So now some people are stuck with properties worth half what they paid (not all RWN members), with no renovation done, and constant repairs and vacancies. 

The very basics would be getting your furniture and shopping list together, keyless entry like Schlage (with backup lockbox with physical key very close as well), looking into insurance, local taxes for STRs, and moreAlot of ways to save time and make it easier to self manage with a property management software like Hospitable and data research like AirDNA.

Also the 1% rule is about as good as the rule thumb and not based on current conditions or current data. 

Check the entire MLS print-out.

Your insurer could recommend one or you can check Google (and, of course, the reviews).

With all this said, to answer your question of how you'd value this for a sale, I'd get a STR specific broker that's able to market your property as a turnkey STR with data on the rents, figures, etc.

I generally rule out most single family homes as viable rentals, as prices are pretty high relative to rents, so aside from some downtown neighborhoods, typically you do not find large areas of single family rental neighborhoods (a median sale price on a 3 bed, 2 bath home so far this year in Dane County on MLS sales data is at $430k). 

Properties typically on a land lease in communities like this are more difficult to get financing on - so not only check the values but also time it takes for these properties to sell to understand your holding costs

He said he would send refund check but have yet to receive as of this post.

Check out the Life Planner by Lucky Life Tools.