This might be a question for our insurance broker/future attorney, but wouldn't the LLC be formed in Indiana since the rental property is located there (versus Illinois where we will be living)?

Instead, create a landing page tailored to your audience with a clear, irresistible offer, such as:"Get a Free Price Comparison Report for Bulk Orders in [Industry/Location].""

If you buy in a prime location with desirable amenities, you’re setting yourself up for steady income and long-term growth.

If you keep it as an investment property, a lot may depend on your location and condition.

What state is the property located in? 

Quote from @Trent Reeve: Quote from @Don Konipol: Quote from @John Brown: I have a friend with a property in a very desirable location in Texas that I believe would be great for STR.

For example college rentals generate some of the highest ROI of properties I come across in New Jersey but it depends on the school and location of property.

But, regardless of the location, Hawaii always has been and always will be a popular, year-round tourist destination.

There are a lot of good things about Wyoming LLCs, but the favorable Wyoming laws don't matter as much because the state you are in will apply the laws of the state the property is located in. 

I'm primarily Texas and Arizona with interest in Huntsville with it as a central hub location for that part of the country.