My suggestion would be to select someone with the most forum posts or most reviews.

Select a plan of action based on your objectives and lifestyle.Remember, every real estate investment journey is unique.

I understand this is could be related to the location and the selection process by our property managers, so any advice is appreciated. 

By having a second pair of eyes throughout the buying and selection process, you'll end up with better metrics and more realistic expectations.

I screen and select tenants that will be stable with limited turnover, and I manage the place well.

How do you find and compensate a good designer for overall material choices and color selections? 

A strong cash offer helps with getting you selected.

They often offer competitive pricing and have a wide selection.- Online retailers: Amazon and Wayfair are good for smaller items like hardware, as you've mentioned.

I am looking for a property management company in the Fort Wayne IN area and came across Select Management Property Pros.

You provide a picture of the room, and then select a theme, and the AI app will show you what the room might look like to give you some ideas and play with different themes.Hope that helps.Mike